Keyboard customization (Karabiner-Elements)

Tool roles, alternatives, selection tradeoffs, and compatibility caveats.

Tool roles, alternatives, selection tradeoffs, and compatibility caveats.

Keyboard customization (Karabiner-Elements)

John uses: Karabiner-Elements (22.5k, Unlicense) with his config written as karabiner.edn compiled by Goku (1.4k, GPL-3.0, last push the example workflow). Section 06's trick: an app-scoped Esc-hold layer in Ghostty fires internal Ctrl+Alt chords that Herdr's [[keys.command]] bindings catch — Karabiner knows the keyboard, Herdr knows the focused pane.

Alternative What it is How it differs License
kanata Cross-platform advanced keyboard remapper (layers, tap-hold) in Rust Works on Linux/Windows/mac; kmonad-style config; no macOS app-scoping as rich as Karabiner's LGPL-3.0
kmonad Advanced keyboard manager (Haskell), layers and macros, cross-platform The original layer-centric remapper; config is Lisp-flavored like Goku's edn MIT
Hammerspoon macOS desktop automation scripted in Lua (hotkeys, window management, app events) Hotkeys plus arbitrary automation logic — can replace the 'chord fires a script' half of John's setup MIT
skhd Simple hotkey daemon for macOS Just hotkey→command bindings in a flat config; minimal but no remapping layers; check current repository activity MIT
Keyboard Maestro Commercial macOS macro platform (hotkeys, palettes, app-scoped macros) GUI macro builder, one-time license; closed source commercial

Pick this if…

  • kanata — you want Karabiner-style layers on Linux or Windows too.
  • kmonad — same, with the original Lisp-flavored config (kin to Goku's edn).
  • Hammerspoon — your chords should run logic, not just keystrokes — it can replace the chord→script half of John's setup.
  • skhd — you only need "hotkey runs command" with no remapping.
  • Keyboard Maestro — you want a GUI and a one-time license instead of config files.

Source references